> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Bulls football blame pie: Breaking down who deserves blame for USF's disappointing 2026 season
- URL: https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/bulls-football-blame-pie-breaking-down-who-deserves-blame-for-usfs-disappointing-2026-season/
- Published: 2026-11-16T14:54:28.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-16T14:54:28.000Z
- Author: Colby Allfrey

There’s no denying that the [South Florida Bulls](https://gousfbulls.com/news/2026/11/13/usf-footballs-furious-rally-comes-up-short-in-loss-to-memphis?ref=bayareaexaminer.com) haven’t met the preseason expectations bestowed upon them by fans, media and their own administration.

USF CEO of Athletics [Rob Higgins](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/rob-higgins-embraces-nil-realignment/) has been clear that the expectation for all of the Bulls’ athletic teams is conference championships.

In most athletic departments around the country, the football team’s success is paramount to the reputation and overall success of a school’s athletic department. USF is no different, and its lack of success this season is magnified to an even more extreme degree due to the program’s inability to appear in a single conference championship game in its 30 years of existence.

Whether fair or not, the expectation for USF in 2026 was to compete for the American Conference championship. The reality for this year’s Bulls football team has been anything but that.

[USF’s loss against Memphis on Thursday night](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/usf-vs-memphis-football-final-score-recap/) was Brian Hartline’s squad’s second straight defeat. The Bulls have now lost four of their past five games against American Conference opponents. USF is now 2-4 in conference play. The Bulls didn’t finish a season below .500 in conference play at all during Alex Golesh’s tenure.

Everyone has a theory for the Bulls’ lackluster play. But in reality, there are multiple culprits for the mediocre, at best, product USF has put on the field this season.

And that calls for one thing: a blame pie chart. I will attach a graphic with the entire blame pie at the end of the article.

## Brian Hartline (30%)

Hartline gets the largest portion of the blame pie as the guy leading the whole operation.

The blame going Hartline’s way is twofold.

The game-day operations for USF have been lackluster at best this season. Both USF’s offense and defense have come up short in key moments of games.

Hartline very obviously tried to build a team that emulated a Big Ten style. USF repeatedly tried to be a team that won by slowing the game down and winning through physicality.

However, it’s evident that Hartline miscalculated how successful that style would be in the American Conference.

The top teams in the American Conference are all teams that spread out the field and play at a fast tempo. In order to win at this level, you have to score big. The top three teams in the standings all rank inside the top five in the league in scoring offense, each averaging 33 points or more.

USF is averaging 27.4 points per game this season. The Bulls have failed to score 20 points on offense in five games this season.

Hartline’s stylistic approach of slowing down the game’s tempo and minimizing the number of possessions each team gets has led to the Bulls playing in five one-score games this season. The problem is that USF is 2-3 in those games.

The Bulls also haven’t cashed in on a plethora of talent in the transfer portal this offseason. USF brought in 41 transfers, and [247Sports](https://247sports.com/season/2026-football/transferteamrankings/?ref=bayareaexaminer.com) rated its transfer class as the best incoming class in the American Conference. 24 of those transfers came from Power Four schools.

However, the Bulls haven’t proven capable of cashing in despite the resources allotted to Hartline and his staff. This USF team has holes all over its offense, and there is a laundry list of players who, when they were brought in, were projected to be key contributors but haven’t lived up to that billing.

Hartline is also responsible for hiring the rest of this offensive staff, which has been much maligned this season.

All of these factors lead to Hartline getting the biggest piece of the blame pie.

> Incredibly telling answer from Brian Hartline about the teams mentality this season.   
>  
> Spoiler alert: he doesn’t seem pleased with it [pic.twitter.com/nqdaaZBrKV](https://t.co/nqdaaZBrKV?ref=bayareaexaminer.com)
> 
> — Colby Allfrey (@AllfreyColby) [November 13, 2026](https://x.com/AllfreyColby/status/2121124046637339072?ref%5Fsrc=twsrc%5Etfw&ref=bayareaexaminer.com)

## Tim Beck (20%)

Speaking of the much-maligned USF offensive staff, let’s talk about Bulls offensive coordinator Tim Beck.

In many ways, Beck has been the scapegoat for this uninspiring Bulls season, a punching bag for frustrated fans.

And while this article is meant to show that the problems go well beyond Beck, he deserves plenty of the flak coming his way.

USF’s offense has been abysmal for the majority of this season. The Bulls rank 11th in the American Conference in total offense, averaging 339.8 yards per game. That number ranks 113th in the FBS.

And while Bulls fans got a reprieve Thursday night with the team producing 552 total yards, it’s been tough sledding for USF’s offense this season. USF has been held under 300 total yards in five of its nine games against FBS opponents this season.

Beck’s playcalling has made finding success on offense the equivalent of trying to swim with a cinder block tied to you.

USF’s offense has been far too predictable this season. The Bulls have run the ball 365 times this season, as opposed to 255 passing attempts. The Bulls rank as the worst team in the country in explosive passing rate, and they rank 134th in the FBS in explosive play rate overall.

The Bulls’ offense has been incredibly easy to defend for large stretches of the season. [The biggest indicator of that is USF’s inability to maintain its offensive success after its opening drives of games.](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/the-definition-of-insanity-usfs-offense-continues-to-repeat-the-same-mistakes/) The Bulls have scored on three straight possessions in only one of their six games against American Conference foes.

USF is also converting just 36.1% of its third-down attempts this season, which ranks 10th in the American. The Bulls rank 112th in the FBS in late-down success rate this season.

Beck’s offense has been woeful for the majority of this season. And while Beck is formulating a game plan around the style Hartline wants, his individual playcalling has been egregiously bad throughout 2026.

## USF’s Offensive Line (15%)

While the playcalling hasn’t been great, there aren’t many play calls that can compensate for an [offensive line](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/where-does-a-wins-a-win-end-and-we/) that can’t hold its own against opposing front sevens.

USF has shuffled through a wide variety of offensive line combinations this season due to injuries and lackluster play.

Seven different USF offensive linemen have played at least 200 snaps this season. None of those players have an overall grade from Pro Football Focus higher than 67.7, with four of those players having grades in the 50s.

The Bulls haven’t been able to protect either of their quarterbacks this season.

USF quarterbacks have been sacked 26 times, the second most by any team in the American Conference. The quarterbacks have been pressured a total of 78 times, which accounts for more than 30% of their dropbacks. The Bulls average just seven yards per passing attempt.

The Bulls have also run into 40 negative plays on the ground this season.

USF’s offensive line has been incapable of keeping the Bulls’ offense on schedule this season. A highly regarded group in the preseason has turned out to be a weakness for the Bulls in 2026.

## Josh Aldridge (10%)

Overall, USF’s defense has been good this season. The Bulls rank inside the top five in the [American Conference](https://theamerican.org/stats.aspx?path=football&year=2026&ref=bayareaexaminer.com) in almost every major statistical category.

However, the Bulls’ defense has crumbled at key moments this season. USF has allowed go-ahead scoring drives in the final eight minutes of the game in each of its four losses this season. Three times, those go-ahead scores occurred when the Bulls were holding a lead.

USF’s defense is littered with talent at all three levels. But in his first season as defensive coordinator, [Josh Aldridge](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/josh-aldridge-and-the-usf-defense/) has at times struggled to fully utilize it.

Despite having a front seven littered with playmakers, the Bulls rank 60th in havoc rate in the country this season. The Bulls’ pass rush does have 24 sacks, but USF has yet to find a way to close out a top-line opponent with its defense.

In fact, USF has only played two offenses that rank inside the top five in the American in scoring: [UTSA](https://www.bayareaexaminer.com/3-takeaways-from-usf-crumbling-at/) and Memphis. The Bulls allowed a combined 83 points in those two games, losing both.

Otherwise, the Bulls have played a cast of mediocre to woeful offenses. That makes USF’s impressive 18.8 points allowed per game seem a little more hollow than meets the eye.

Overall, Aldridge hasn’t seemed to get the most out of this talented Bulls defense this season. The Bulls’ defense has yet to show that it can win them a game against a strong opponent.

## USF’s Pass Catchers (10%)

One of the most anticipated things about this year’s Bulls squad was the first-year wide receiver room under Hartline, whose pedigree in developing wide receivers was legendary.

But USF’s wide receiving corps this season has been a forgettable group.

The Bulls don’t have a pass catcher who has reached 500 yards on the season through five games. USF doesn’t have anybody inside the top 12 in the American Conference in receiving yards.

Bryson Rogers leads the Bulls with 44 catches for 444 yards this season. However, the former four-star recruit hasn’t been a true No. 1 target for his hometown Bulls squad. That was best encapsulated Thursday night when Rogers let a potential go-ahead touchdown pass late in the fourth quarter go right through his hands.

Otherwise, the Bulls don’t have a receiver with more than 300 yards this season. USF has 17 drops and just 15 contested catches this season.

Preseason returners Mudia Reuben and Wyatt Sullivan have severely underperformed in their final collegiate seasons. Reuben has 10 catches for 227 yards, while Sullivan has 12 catches for 93 yards this season.

USF’s receivers haven’t been reliable, they haven’t been explosive and they haven’t met expectations in Year 1 of Hartline’s tenure.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/77/a9/77a9bb8f-d0f1-45b5-8fed-5feacd465ef5/content/images/2026/11/USF_TEM147478.jpeg)

Bryson Rogers leads USF in receiving yards this season. Austin Vogl | Bay Area Examiner

## Michael Van Buren Jr. (5%)

Michael Van Buren Jr. has missed the majority of the Bulls’ last three games with an injury. And in a lot of ways, USF’s offense has looked better with Luke Kromenhoek leading it.

Van Buren Jr. completed 63.9% of his passes for 1,273 passing yards and six touchdown passes in his eight starts this season.

Early in the season, Van Buren Jr. showed flashes of brilliance with 539 passing yards combined in two games against Army and Delaware State in Weeks 2 and 3\. However, Van Buren Jr. passed for 205 yards or fewer in each of his next four full games.

As the pressure on Van Buren Jr. increased, so did his struggles. He completed just 45.2% of his passes when under pressure this season.

Overall, Van Buren Jr.’s command of the offense started to slip as the season went on. And the insertion of Kromenhoek has made that even more apparent, as the Bulls’ offense has improved in recent weeks.

Van Buren Jr.’s play undoubtedly held USF’s offense back this season.

## Rob Higgins (5%)

It has been a less-than-ideal fall for Higgins and USF athletics.

On Thursday night, I watched as Higgins quietly stood on the sidelines, visibly frustrated as USF fell to Memphis. The combination of his lifetime ties to USF and his tied fate to the coaches he hires has to make for a brutal postgame feeling.

However, even with frustration rising regarding USF athletics as a whole this fall, it’s hard to blame Higgins too much for the football team’s struggles.

Higgins’ hire of Hartline was praised at the time, and it is still far too early to rule out success for Hartline in the coming seasons.

I also am not going to blame Higgins for Hartline hiring Beck. It is normal for athletic directors to give their coaches the liberty to hire the coordinators they want. And while maybe Higgins could have forced Hartline to go further outside of his comfort zone in hiring a playcaller, it would have been far more concerning if Higgins had fully taken the reins and hired an offensive coordinator himself.

And while Higgins has to get a small piece of the blame pie due to putting Hartline in place to lead the Bulls, it’s not time to give up on Higgins’ vision, especially when he has done so much to provide Bulls athletics with the funds to succeed.

## American Conference (5%)

The biggest gripe the Bulls can have with the American this season is the fact that they have had to play on back-to-back short weeks.

USF played on Friday night last week and Thursday night this week. In total, the Memphis game marked the Bulls’ third game in 12 days. That is a tough slate for any team to deal with.

The Bulls also had to play UTSA on a short week. That means the two best offenses USF has had to play this season came with short weeks to prepare.

All teams in the American have to deal with short weeks. However, USF’s recent schedule has been hard to overcome in recent weeks.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/77/a9/77a9bb8f-d0f1-45b5-8fed-5feacd465ef5/content/images/2026/11/pie.png)

The Full Bulls Football Blame Pie for the 2026 season.